The SIO2 project
  1. The SIO2 project
  2. SIO-2035

Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

        Details

        • Type: Improvement Improvement
        • Status: Resolved Resolved
        • Priority: Major Major
        • Resolution: Fixed
        • Affects Version/s: Current Version
        • Fix Version/s: None
        • Component/s: OIOIOI
        • Labels:

          Description

          Currently, reporting a forum post takes a single click on a link next to the post.
          There's also no way to provide an explanation of why the post was reported.
          This makes it very easy to accidentally report some posts, while making it hard for contest admins to go through the reports and decide which ones are legitimate and which are not.

          Some users (participants and juree members alike) have been complaining about this:
          https://sio2.mimuw.edu.pl/c/oi25-1/forum/62/654/

          One way of solving it would be to make the "report" link redirect to a form where the user could fill in the reason for reporting the post, and confirm that they indeed want to make the report. The user could also go back if they clicked on the "report" link by accident.

            Activity

            Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order
            Hide
            Permalink
            Szymon Acedański added a comment -
            This issue has been automatically closed as Obsolete due to no activity for 365 days.

            Feel free to reopen it or create a new one if it's still relevant.
            Show
            Szymon Acedański added a comment - This issue has been automatically closed as Obsolete due to no activity for 365 days. Feel free to reopen it or create a new one if it's still relevant.
            Hide
            Permalink
            Wojciech Dubiel added a comment - - edited
            This is still a problem
            Show
            Wojciech Dubiel added a comment - - edited This is still a problem
            Hide
            Permalink
            Jakub Niściór added a comment -
            It is also worth to see the content of the forum post in the deletation/reporting confirmation view.
            Show
            Jakub Niściór added a comment - It is also worth to see the content of the forum post in the deletation/reporting confirmation view.
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 1
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 1 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 2
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 2 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 3
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 3 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 4
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 4 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 5
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 5 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 6
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 6 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Hide
            Permalink
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment -
            Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 7
            https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550

            SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post.

            Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text,
            Added Report confirmation, updated tests.

            Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf
            Show
            Gerrit Gerrit added a comment - Change oioioi~master~Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf, patchset 7 https://gerrit.sio2project.mimuw.edu.pl/3550 SIO-2035 Require explaining the reason when reporting a forum post. Delete confirmation view: showing post formatted as post, not as plain text, Added Report confirmation, updated tests. Change-Id: Ie46f511fb72d8f09282a2df5450eee6cc3da70cf

              People

              • Assignee:
                Wojciech Dubiel
                Reporter:
                Wojciech Dubiel
              • Votes:
                0 Vote for this issue
                Watchers:
                4 Start watching this issue

                Dates

                • Created:
                  Updated:
                  Resolved: